Instant replays are all over the World Cup now.
We can roll back the tape to reevaluate history in real-time.
Baseball is doing this new thing where they allow the players to challenge the umpire’s call by tapping their helmet. I first saw it in the minor leagues, but it’s now in all the games.
After the tap, the play is reviewed by a computer (AI?), which can easily tell if the ball was in the strike zone. Then the call is either underscored or overturned.
I heard a guy on NPR talking about this, and he brought up something I witnessed myself at the minor league games.
The crowd loves this new ruling.
Whenever someone taps their helmet, it’s like a betting pool opens up, but not with money, with emotion. We all have our opinions out there in the bleachers, and we let them be known. Both sides are equally confident.
Great call. Totally a strike.
That was a bullsh*t call. Not even close.
It’s almost like religion.
My God.
No, my God.
No! No God.
And we’re all right.
Right?
And then the loudspeaker comes on: The call is overturned. It’s a ball!
Half the crowd goes wild with excitement and half the crowd boos and jeers… middle fingers, high fives, arms thrown up, c’mon! beer spilling, and all of it directed at the umpire who, though doing his best, is the scapegoat placed there for us hate.
I’m guilty of it too. I do those high fives. I scream at the TV during the World Cup, text my disdain to friends. You get caught up in it. It feels great to slap literal and proverbial hands with people.
I just wish it wasn’t only for that.
Having a common enemy, in this case, a portly umpire or neon-shirted referree, bonds people together, but the glue is cheap and it doesn’t last. We become friends with strangers in the moment. Hands reach toward each other, and I suppose I should be happy about that.
But all I can think about as the applause dies down, and we resume our perches to vulture-watch the next call, is how fleeting the good vibe was.
How often do we reach out to each other only to put someone else down?
This is now a tactic of professional sports: to rally fans around their anger toward the umpire AGAIN. It’s a second chance to stoke the flames of anger and joy. To fuel us.
Like war.
Like the schoolyard.
We do this a lot: using hate to build alliances — hate exhumed from the belly and brought up to the surface, tacky and gooey.
It works long enough to give the illusion that we’re together. Alas, we are not; we’ll filter out into the parking lot and into the classrooms quite separately. That is, if we lose. If we win, we will dance.
Reticent free thinkers plagued with a legacy of tribalism.
Searching for something good with primitive tools.
Pitchforks, cudgels, torches…
And cheap glue.
